Facebook, and related internet social networking sites, don’t make you more friends:
Social networking sites like Facebook and MySpace do not help you make more genuine close friends, according to a survey by researchers who studied how the websites are changing the nature of friendship networks.
Although social networking on the internet helps people to collect hundreds or even thousands of acquaintances, the researchers believe that face to face contact is nearly always necessary to form truly close friendships.“Although the numbers of friends people have on these sites can be massive, the actual number of close friends is approximately the same in the face to face real world,” said Will Reader at Sheffield Hallam University.
I’m not surprised by this. My close circle of friends are still the ones I met the natural genetically-optimized way: in meatspace. I occasionally bump into a fellow Myspacer who recognizes me through their computer monitor, but we hardly ever move the interaction past the obligatory hellos.
Facebook and Myspace are one part attention whore canvas, one part Creative Class Rolodex, and one part alter ego resume. They basically serve as outlets for people, especially younger women, to “express themselves” and climb the status ladder by demonstrating their social value through their meme-generating links, musical tastes, witticisms, “spontaneous” nightclub photos, and vapid hourly updates on the daily tedium of their lives. When they’re not stamping the internet world with their unoriginal brand of detached irony, they use these sites to herd their threadbare acquaintances into one easily managed electronic address book, keeping tabs on everyone, like ranchers herding steer. It’s a social butterfly’s dream come true! Wide… but shallow.
Ultimately, friendships live and die by trust. No one becomes your good friend until they, and you, have earned each other’s trust. And that is where sites like Facebook fail:
But to develop a real friendship we need to see that the other person is trustworthy. “We invest time and effort in them in the hope that sometime they will help us out. It is a kind of reciprocal relationship,” said Dr Reader, “What we need is to be absolutely sure that a person is really going to invest in us, is really going to be there for us when we need them…It’s very easy to be deceptive on the internet.”
That’s the key right there. With a few vaguely intriguing photos (action shots work best for guys, semi-porn snapshots for girls), a list of concert tour dates, and insidery jokes from people leaving comments on your profile, a person can present him or herself in a way that is at odds with reality. We are making friends with digital people whose first impressions have been micromanaged and painstakingly handcrafted for hours (sometimes weeks!) beforehand. You’ll never truly know someone’s character unless you engage them in realtime where a raised eyebrow or a sly smile can carry more vital information than pages of spoogy internet masturbation.
It reminds me of a girl I once dated whose Myspace page was a months-long project of webdesigner-looking social status achievement. I met her at a bar before I knew about her Myspace page. Later, when she showed me her profile, I couldn’t believe the disconnect between her sweet real self and the raging sassypants she presented online.
Because I have advanced ADD, I get bored on these sites after two minutes. I need to see the person I’m talking to at least once in a while or I won’t put in any effort to maintain the friendship. Give me real life over this pointless shit any day.
Btw, I’m on Facebook. You can find me under killa, killing your beta zombie.

Wait a minute, aren’t you just supposed to be facebook friends after you’re real friends (met in person)? I didn’t get the memo.
LikeLike
very few people meet on facebook. i’m on it 7447146174617817 a day to do the following:
– read people’s blogs who only post them on fbook
– put up photos of my excessively fun life
– play scrabulous
– write cute notes & messages
– stalk
it has become, however, a new means of communication, to add to the phone and IM. It’s like a social virtual space to connect to people you already know in unique ways. It also helps me stay in touch with distant friends without having to do the formal calls or e-mails. It’s the lack of formality that people enjoy.
(you know what’s funny, i know *exactly* who you’re describing here)
And yes, it is very easy to be deceptive on the internet. 😉
LikeLike
Someone finally beat me in Scrabble. It was an intense game.
LikeLike
I think the most interesting thing is how fast before a girl facebook friends me. One time, a girl grabbed my computer the morning after staying over and facebooked me. Needless to say I never spoke to her again.
I’m also curious about the people who insist that they won’t join any social networking site and don’t use any form of instant messenger. For the 20-25 crowd I get weirded out by this. Are they saying their too cool for technology or just do dumb to know how to use it properly? Either way it’s almost as big of a turn off, as the girl who’s favorite music includes last week’s top 10 list.
LikeLike
Maybe I’m just old and senile, but I simply don’t “get” the point of MySpace and Facebook. Not in the least.
LikeLike
nullp0inter you should play my roommate. you two are pretty even and both able to beat me without even trying
LikeLike
i need to face my bold-faced facebook lies…
poke me!
LikeLike
Peter, narcissism. nuff said.
LikeLike
How do people WANT others to see them vs. how do people actually see us? What social level do we want to have vs. what we actually have?
Facebook is merely the precursor to the slow but accelerating death of the face to face world. Sure, trust is important. But when everyone is plugged into the virtual world and our own thoughts become electrical signals, what is the face to face world anymore? What is the individual, anymore? What is a friend when there are billions of people at our fingertips and we all have access to the same information and speak the same language?
We are all one.
Om.
LikeLike
Great post! Well written, and thorougly researched. Keep em coming.
LikeLike
I second Peter’s old-guy bewilderment. I signed up for Facebook out of curiosity, but after spending a couple of hours clicking here and there I couldn’t for the life of me come up with a single reason why it might be of any use to me. But maybe I’ve just been left in the dust. The web 1.0 world of email, blogs, and websites I’ve adapted to and kinda like. All this post web-2.0 stuff, though … It’s one paradigm shift too many for me.
LikeLike
“Raging sassypants”?
Myspace and Facebook are all about building a narcissistic shrine to oneself and hoping that other people notice how awesome one is. In other words, it’s a lot like real life.
LikeLike
A lot of “badass bitch” female bloggers suffer from this syndrome as well.
LikeLike
This article scared me the hell away from using Facebook.
LikeLike
Oh, and for the reason why Internet acquaintances never grow much bigger than real life acquaintances, you should google “Dunbar’s number.” Fascinating stuff.
LikeLike
“I think the most interesting thing is how fast before a girl facebook friends me”
It’s funny when a girl adds you to her FB and you never even told her your last name. And it isn’t like “Robert” is exceedingly uncommon, either.
I took an 8 month hiatus from the website. It’s an absolutely disgusting exercise in chest beating and increasing self-esteem unjustly. I reactivated my account a while back so that I could access my friends pictures more easily: for some reason, they have an objection to flickr.
LikeLike
…a person can present him or herself in a way that is at odds with reality….
you mean the same way one can do with a blog?
You’ll never truly know someone’s character unless you engage them in realtime.
agreed. and spend 10 minutes surveying a person’s bathroom, bedroom and refridgerator and you’ll learn more about that person than 20 hours of conversation.
social networks is the norm for generation y and beyond. older generations “don’t get them” b/c they can’t imagine living life so transparently. of course, there will be repercussions of doing so. but also great benefits. while i agree there is truth to the me generation, younger generations are more globally aware and socially conscious. the beauty of social networks is access to information, which levels manufactured hierarchies imposed by governments, corporations, etc. and facilitates change more easily. hte singularity is near.
LikeLike
older generations “don’t get them” b/c they can’t imagine living life so transparently.
Very true. I’m in my mid-30s even though I don’t have a blog nor do I make terribly controversial comments online, I feel very protective of my privacy. I can’t imagine posting my photo, details of my wherabouts or line of work, or real name online, like some of the younger bloggers do.
LikeLike
…. or even older writers/bloggers with families and real-life jobs, like Sailer or The Derb do.
LikeLike
ps – gored. good one.
LikeLike
Facebook’s an excellent tool if you have friends and family all over the world/globe or if you’re at college. I can’t afford to be jetsetting all the time, talking to them on msn or wasting text/phonetime on them.
It just helps keeping track of events/parties, birthdays, what people are upto (and where they are) and even other people’s timetables should you want to see when they have free time.
However, it is definitely not getting you laid if you don’t know the person. A random guy asked me out on it and it’s frankly just wierd if you’ve not even physically met the person. On the other hand, another guy with an attractive picture who I was sure I did not know wanted to add me as a friend and I did actually hesitate over the ‘ignore…’ button.
There are disadvantages:
A) It may waste your time if you’re the type of person that can be easily distracted by quizzes/applications/random games.
B) There is no way one could say in the ‘looking for’ status ‘Strictly religious, marriage only’. 🙂
It’s a fun application for sociable, young people or sociable older persons both groups of which have plenty of spare time and plenty of junk to forward (absolutely do not get any of the super/funwalls) who circulate within circles wherein they meet each other repeatedly, yet not form deep relationships.
LikeLike
I’m on Facebook because it’s a handy way to keep in touch with friends who live all over the world, share photos, or kill time. What I don’t get are the people who have 100+ “friends.” I’m a very sociable person, and I sure as hell don’t have that many friends.
LikeLike